Day 46, Part 2

“The unexamined life is not worth living.”

-Socrates

Since there have been a few negative reactions to my anticlimactic journey’s final post, I thought I’d take a moment to clarify. Following that, the world is free to agree or disagree with me.

In short, some of my final Day 46 remarks offended a few of my Catholic readers. I’ve read it over a few times and have decided to talk about three areas of the post to clarify my thoughts and language. Clarity ┬áis always helpful–after drinking beer and eating no food for 46 days, I hope folks will understand that fatigue was certainly setting in. That I didn’t get grumpy and blatantly attack the neo-prohibitionist denominations out there during this journey is a minor miracle.

In addition to putting up 46 generally pensive posts, as well as conducting countless interviews and writing a whole lot more on my own time, it’s easy for me to have forgotten what I said, did or wrote where. Further, many blog posts, and certainly all of these, are basically short, first-drafts. On top of this “part-time” project, I have a family and full-time job.

Offensive Statement #1

“Some Catholics have construed the spiritual element of my journey to be my willingness to give penance.”

Reason #1

This wasn’t a broad-brushed indictment on the Catholic church. This was a statement made in response to comments or emails I’ve received in the last few weeks. People alluded to my willingness to give penance in this way. But as I’ve said from the beginning, this isn’t why I took on the project. The second part of the opening paragraph explains why: “my historical study into this beer legend.” As I said, I had an “openness to spiritually-thrust enlightenment.” But that wasn’t the primary reason for the project. The media hasn’t been helpful. I’ve been clear about my intentions, but some TV stations and print publications sidestepped my clarity. Or they used sub-headers like, “and he’s doing it for religious reasons.”

Not exactly. I clarified that whenever I was live somewhere, whenever I could fit it in.

Offensive Statement #2

“I believe that God forgives when we ask it, and not for the number of Our Fathers or Hail Marys we lift up or for simply attending confession.”

Reason #2

I don’t have a problem with Our Fathers or Hail Marys or confession. I think they have value. I simply stated that “I believe that God forgives when we ask it” and that “Confession and forgiveness can happen anywhere.” If someone wants to dispute that “maintaining an open communication line with God” is a lousy idea, I’d like to hear their arguments, though I’ll be honest, I’m not likely to buy them.

One piece of this story that really didn’t make it to the blog was my time at Conception Abbey. It was an amazing, eye-opening experience, and I wrote 14 pages while I was down there. I acquired a new respect for the Catholic church while I was there, but only posted a short piece of video to cover that time. I wasn’t going to post 14 pages on a blog and I didn’t know where to start to distill it down.

Offensive Statement #3

“Confession and forgiveness can happen anywhere, and the key is more about maintaining an open communication line with God, and not in donning a suit and nodding off for an hour on Sundays. Sitting in a church doesn’t make one a Christian any more than sitting in a garage makes one a car.”

Reason #3

Just because this project started with a group of Catholic monks, doesn’t mean that my thoughts are limited to the Catholic denomination. As I’ve said before, I don’t care about denominations. The common denominator among them is Christ. That’s the part that I personally choose to focus on. So it’s important for me to point out that people don suits in all churches and don’t necessarily take Christ seriously in their lives.

I grew up in a small town where everybody knows everybody, and occasionally my mom forced me to go to church. There, I found people who surprised me. I’d seen them in other contexts, and the church didn’t seem to “suit” them. That’s a problem I’ve had with Christians all my life. Some of them are poseurs. And that cuts across all denominations.

Other thoughts

The aforementioned words by Socrates sum up my view on life. I asked a lot of questions about God and the church when I was a kid, and I shied well away from them both for a long time. Not everyone who was brought up Catholic stays there. They call themselves “recovering Catholics.” For some, it happens the other way around. Some come to God having been brought up with no church background at all.

We are all different. Thank God.

I still interrogate life and God and the church. If I’m to crack on this denomination or that, it would be the ones who pretend that Jesus didn’t drink wine (or wine with alcohol in it) or don’t acknowledge that the Bible contains 27 references to wine as a blessing or 20 references to the loss of wine or strong drink as an example of God’s curse.

I’m a nice guy, but some things need not be sugar-coated. During Day 46, I had more in my head than I had contained in the post, and for that, I’m sorry.

Unfortunately, these issues distracted a few from some of the “meat” of the post, in which I challenged myself to continue “always on the path, always growing.” I mentioned that I had discovered as so many from cultures all across the globe had before me, that there is a lot of value to fasting. My experience reinforced my beliefs that today’s culture of excess breeds waste and gluttony. I discovered that my body (and probably yours too) is capable of so much more than I could ever fully realize.

With any luck, I’ll have the good sense to apply these tidbits to my life.

Cheers, all!

J.

About these ads

About Wilson

J. Wilson is an award-winning homebrewer, BJCP judge and pretty good dad. View all posts by Wilson

11 responses to “Day 46, Part 2

  • John

    No offense was taken by this Catholic! Some people perhaps just try to find something offensive no matter what you write…

  • bladdamasta

    I really enjoyed reading this post. I’m a lazy Catholic and could relate to many of your sentiments. I took no offense at any of your first post and reckon that your second more than articulately “endeth” the tale.

    You owe no apology to anyone and I thank you for being so sharing with us on your journey. At http://www.Backoftheferry.wordpress.com we would be interested to know your first meal and have you had a big night out since.

    There’s a beer awaiting you on the Back of the Ferry if you can get to Australia.

    As I said we enjoyed the journey and ignore the knockers. They couldn’t have fun at an open bar.

  • Stephen Blazynski

    This Catholic in the UK isn’t offended either. I remember being awestruck when a priest (during his homily) used the garage/church analogy. It was a homily that stuck in my mind. The discomfiture of some of the congregation was very evident!! An Anglican friend of mine put it another way: ” God came to comfort the discomforted and to discomfort the comfortable!”. Congratulations on reaching the end of the road. Tahank you for sharing your journeyn with us.

  • Ginny Morris

    I’m a Catholic, too. No offense taken here in any way! Tell them to “get a grip.”

  • Linda Conley

    Thank you for your final comments. I completely agree: it is with Christ that we walk, after all. You’ve been an inspiration to all of us and I hated to detract from that but I was kind of surprised and hurt by your final comments. As GB Shaw writes: there is no accounting for taste; and I would add, there is no accounting for what hurts one and might not another. And so it was with me. Thank you for addressing this. God bless you and your wife and your young children. You’ve got a strength of purpose most of us simply envy.

  • Aaron Jarrell

    J. I would like to say that I think its crazy that you have to post another part to your final. I believe that people are taking things WAY to literally and this makes me a bit dissapointed in our society that you cannot say something without offending so many people. I feel that if they don’t like it they should read another blog. Personally I completely agree with you.
    On another note I hope your bacon smoothie or whatever you decided to have was all you had been hoping for.
    Cheers,
    Aaron

  • Ryan

    I was unoffended by your post as well, but wanted to clear some things up:

    1. Catholics, before they attend confession, are asked to do an “examination of conscience,” which, in part, is your own personal confession to God, naming your sins, and asking for forgiveness for them.

    2. “Just going to confession” is really quite nice if you have a good confessor (a priest who will guide you to eliminate the sins you are committing).Confession is completely anonymous (you can go to any priest at any parish) and, personally, I feel very well after Confession.

    3. Catholics believe that God gave us the sacraments as visible signs of invisible grace. These sacraments are all things that Jesus did during his life (including forgiving sins) and, as we believe, passed onto his priests to continue after his earthly departure.

    Anyway, a bit more on the matter, if you are interested:

    http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0110sbs.asp

    http://scripturecatholic.com/confession.html

  • Hugh

    Bravo! I found your blog late, but read all your posts and really enjoyed following your journey. I spread the word to all my fellow beer-drinking Christians.

    I hope you won’t end your blog here; I’d be very interested to read about your thoughts (and the physical effects) after a few days or weeks.

    Happy Easter!

  • Steph

    I’m a Catholic as well, and although I was not offended by your part 1 post, I was a little put off by the remarks. I really appreciate this clarification and it shows a lot about your character that you would follow up and respond to your reader’s opinions.

    Yes, it is your blog and you can do with it what you wish. However, it takes a good man to be able to admit that perhaps his words were misunderstood and to provide clarification. I’ve been reading since the beginning (but not commenting) and am glad you’re going out on this note. Thanks for letting me follow your journey.

  • Morgan

    I just wanted to say that i really liked your blog. I have been a subscriber from nearly the beginning and have read every post. I’m quite experienced with fasting and i like to learn about other peoples experiences. I found your reporting really edifying.

    I’d like to hear about your fast breaking experience if you have any thoughts you’re willing to share.

    Once again, thank you for sharing your experience.

  • Bob

    Catholic, and offended.

    The comments made were clearly anti-Catholic, unnecessary and distracting from the stated purpose of this blog.

    No apology should every include a “but”. “But” erodes the sincerity and reveals the true intent of a masked apology. This was no apology, but a mere rebuttal to legitimate criticism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 48 other followers

%d bloggers like this: